Luxury Car Rentals on Casey Key

An exotic fleet defined by power, prestige and understated luxury.

Call Now

Winter Wheels DEAL is Here!

Enjoy 20% savings on our entire fleet.

Use code SRQ20 at checkout for
trips from Dec 15 to Feb 12.

(Blackout Dates: Dec 24–Jan 4)

Reserve Now

A Private Gulf Coast Enclave

Casey Key is one of Southwest Florida’s most exclusive barrier islands, known for unspoiled beaches, limited development, and a distinctly quiet sense of luxury. Located just south of Siesta Key between the Gulf of America and Little Sarasota Bay, it offers a level of privacy and serenity that sets it apart. This is a destination where discretion matters—and where refined transportation feels essential.

Scenic Drives & Secluded Beaches

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - Aerial view of waterfront houses with docks along a coastal area, with the ocean in the background and sunshine reflecting on the water.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - Aerial view of residential homes along the coast with colorful, ocean, and waterway in Florida

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - A large beachfront house with a red tile roof, surrounded by palm trees, overlooking the ocean at sunset.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - A coastal street lined with palm trees and large white houses.

The drive along Casey Key Road is among the most scenic in the region, winding past historic waterfront homes, lush landscaping, and uninterrupted water views. Enjoying this stretch in a luxury convertible rental or premium SUV rental allows you to move at an unhurried pace, fully immersed in the surroundings. Quiet beach access points reveal wide, pristine shorelines ideal for morning walks, shelling, and sunset views—often shared by very few.

Nearby Dining & Coastal Access

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - Aerial view of waterfront houses and condos along a canal with the ocean in the background.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - A scenic street lined with palm trees on one side and white buildings with arches on the other, with a view of the ocean in the background under a clear blue sky.

While Casey Key itself remains intentionally tranquil, excellent dining and amenities are just minutes away. To the north, Siesta Key offers lively waterfront restaurants and nightlife, while Nokomis and Venice to the south provide charming downtowns and refined local dining. A luxury rental vehicle allows comfortable movement between these destinations—preserving the calm of Casey Key while keeping everything within easy reach.

Where to Stay

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - View from a shaded beach hut with a thatched roof, looking out over a sandy beach, palm trees, and the ocean under a clear blue sky.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - Front view of a white luxury SUV parked on grass in front of a large house with a manicured lawn, flower beds, and American flags.

Casey Key is defined by private luxury residences and high-end vacation rentals, many with direct Gulf or bay frontage. These homes are ideal for travelers seeking space, discretion, and a truly secluded coastal stay. With limited commercial development on the island, a luxury rental SUV or touring vehicle ensures effortless access to shopping, dining, and cultural experiences nearby.

Outdoor & Leisure Experiences

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - A golf course with well-maintained green grass, sand bunkers, a water hazard, trees, and a clear blue sky in the background.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - Aerial view of houses by a shoreline at sunset, with water, boats, and a colorful sky.

Sarasota Motor Club - Exotic Car Consignment Sarasota - A woman on a paddleboard in clear water near a rocky shore, with a background of palm trees and a bright blue sky.

From kayaking and paddleboarding along Little Sarasota Bay to boating, fishing, and nearby nature preserves, Casey Key is well suited for outdoor exploration. Championship golf courses, galleries, and performing arts venues in Osprey, Venice, and Sarasota are all a short scenic drive away—making every outing part of a curated Gulf Coast experience.

Drive Around Casey Key

Sarasota Motor Club offers professional delivery and pickup of luxury rental vehicles to Casey Key. Your vehicle arrives professionally detailed, fueled, and ready—eliminating logistical concerns while maintaining the discretion and ease this destination demands.